Exploring Cayucos: Finding a Second Home and Investment Opportunities

If you’re considering purchasing property in the idyllic beach town of Cayucos, 2025 presents a host of opportunities to secure your dream home or investment. From ocean-view cottages to spacious hillside retreats, there’s something for everyone in this coastal gem.

Below, we’ve broken down key listings, their unique features, and who they might be perfect for.

2025 Cass Ave – $1,125,000

• Details: 1 bed, 1 bath, 570 sqft, 3,000 sqft lot.

• Highlights: A cozy beach cottage with unblockable ocean views, refurbished interiors, and approved plans for a future two-story home.

• Ideal For: Investors or buyers seeking a weekend getaway with expansion potential.

• Value: While compact, the $1,973.68 per sqft price reflects its prime location and future development possibilities.

3516 Shearer Ave – $1,195,000

• Details: 2 beds, 1.5 baths, 1,498 sqft, 2,450 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Ocean views, vaulted ceilings, and $120K in updates, including a new roof and decking.

• Ideal For: Buyers wanting a move-in-ready home with modern upgrades.

• Value: At $797.73 per sqft, it’s reasonably priced for its condition and location.

46 20th St – $1,250,000

• Details: 2 beds, 1 bath, 810 sqft, 3,000 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Refurbished vintage cottage with updated infrastructure and close beach access.

• Ideal For: Small families, retirees, or those seeking a well-maintained beach home.

• Value: Upgraded plumbing and electrical make this home move-in-ready, with minimal maintenance required.

833 Park Ave – $1,299,000

• Details: 3 beds, 3 baths, 1,394 sqft, 2,614 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Multi-level home with panoramic ocean views, vaulted ceilings, and multiple decks.

• Ideal For: Families or investors looking for a unique home with character and rental potential.

• Value: At $931.85 per sqft, this home strikes a balance between price and features.

126 Birch Ave – $1,449,000

• Details: 4 beds, 2 baths, 2,016 sqft, 7,500 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Spacious home with a large backyard, close to downtown and the beach.

• Ideal For: Families or buyers seeking room to expand with options like an ADU.

• Value: The $718.75 per sqft price reflects the potential for customization and a desirable location.

2725 Richard Ave – $1,350,000

• Details: 2 beds, 1.5 baths, 1,457 sqft, 3,125 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Licensed short-term rental with sweeping panoramic views and a multi-level layout.

• Ideal For: Investors or vacation homeowners looking for rental income potential.

• Value: The licensed rental status is a key feature for long-term ROI.

40 15th St – $1,500,000

• Details: 2 beds, 2 baths, 1,125 sqft, 4,500 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Ocean views, a large backyard, and close proximity to the beach.

• Ideal For: Retirees or those looking for a quiet, scenic retreat.

• Value: Priced high at $1,333.33 per sqft, but the location and views justify the cost.

3408 Davies Ave – $2,141,000

• Details: 3 beds, 3 baths, 2,401 sqft, 4,200 sqft lot.

• Highlights: Sweeping 270-degree ocean views, owned solar, and a luxurious layout with multiple decks.

• Ideal For: Luxury buyers or those seeking a turnkey home for entertaining.

• Value: At $891.71 per sqft, this home delivers exceptional amenities and energy efficiency.

Why Cayucos?

Cayucos offers more than just beautiful properties; it’s a haven for nature lovers, with stunning beaches, a tight-knit community, and a relaxed pace of life. Whether you’re looking for a vacation home, rental investment, or a full-time residence, these listings highlight the diversity and appeal of this Central Coast destination.

Let me help you find your perfect property in Cayucos. Whether it’s a vintage cottage, a modern retreat, or a luxurious escape, the Central Coast has it all.