Two Arroyo Grande Homes Offering Unique Opportunities for Buyers

Justin Stoner
Apr 29
2 min read

If you're looking for homes in Arroyo Grande, two new listings offer very different but equally appealing options depending on what you want most: history and character, or modern updates and easy living.

Here’s a closer look:

555 Le Point Street, Arroyo Grande — $1,125,000

This historic 4-bedroom, 2-bath home is one of Arroyo Grande’s original homesteads, built around 1900. It sits on Crown Hill, offering walkable access to Arroyo Grande Village shops, restaurants, and coffee houses.

Why it stands out:

One of the earliest properties in the Village, preserving original character with modern upgrades.
Features high ceilings, a gourmet kitchen with top-end appliances, and a landscaped garden perfect for relaxing or entertaining.
Views of the neighborhood from the elevated Crown Hill location.
Seller is offering a $35,000 rate buy-down, helping buyers manage higher mortgage rates.

Who it's for:

Buyers who value historic homes and a strong sense of place.
Retirees or second-home buyers who want walkability and charm.
Professionals or creatives looking for a distinctive home in a vibrant location.

Things to consider:

No garage.
Two-story layout.
No cooling system, though heating is in place with fireplaces and forced air.

525 May Street, Arroyo Grande — $1,250,000

This 3-bedroom, 2-bath single-level home offers 1,800 square feet of updated living space on a quiet cul-de-sac near Arroyo Grande Village. Built in 1982, it has been thoughtfully remodeled to suit modern living while maintaining a cozy feel.

Why it stands out:

Fully remodeled kitchen with modern finishes and newer appliances.
Spa-like master bathroom and updated hall bath.
Additional pantry and storage space, including a butcher’s pantry for food prep.
Landscaped backyard featuring mature greenery, planter beds, a wood patio deck, and a variety of fruit trees (lemon, lime, apricot, peach, apple, fig, and orange).
Quiet street location with open space and a seasonal creek behind the property.

Who it's for:

Retirees wanting a move-in ready, low-maintenance home on a single level.
Small families needing open space inside and a functional backyard outside.
Buyers looking for updated finishes without the need for major renovations.

Things to consider:

No cooling system, but newer dual-pane windows are installed.
Enclosed sunroom addition increases usable space but may not be fully permitted (something to confirm during inspections).

Quick Side-by-Side Comparison

Address	Best For	Key Highlights
555 Le Point St	Historic home lovers, walkability seekers	Historic charm, rate buy-down offered
525 May St	Retirees, small families, modern updates	Updated single-story, beautiful backyard